Akron
Beacon Journal...
Free
of bias
August 6, 2011
Jon
Husted wants to make sure that
when voters consider Issue 3 on the statewide ballot in November, they
see a
title that is fair and not loaded with political freight.
And
well he should. The Ohio secretary
of state and chairman of the state’s ballot board has final say on the
wording
of the titles of ballot issues. He has to finalize the title by the end
of the
month.
Issue
3 proposes an amendment to the
state constitution. If a majority of voters approve it, the amendment
would
mean the provision in the federal health-care law that requires
individuals to
buy health insurance or otherwise pay a fine would not apply in Ohio.
The
reform law, in particular the
so-called individual mandate, does not lack controversy, as it is. Ohio
already
is party with 20 other states in a lawsuit challenging the
constitutionality of
the mandate.
The
state ballot initiative reflects
the heated national debate. Words matter. A title that is couched in
neutral
language is essential to avoid swaying voters one way or the other.
Unfortunately,
as drafted — “To
preserve the freedom of Ohioans to choose their health care and health
care
coverage ” — the title is anything but neutral. The word “freedom” in
the title
consciously carries over the contentious notion of “socialized
medicine,” of a
federal government out of control, snatching away personal freedoms and
choices
in health care.
The
decision Ohioans have to make
regarding the individual mandate is whether government has an
obligation to
level the health-care field in such a way that citizens have access to
reasonable choices for affordable care when they get sick (which they
do at one
time or another) and that the burden of such care does not fall
disproportionately
on those who pay for coverage. Should the insured in Ohio consider it
their
“freedom” or their “choice” to pay for those who won’t buy health
insurance? As
Husted well understands, his obligation is to ensure that the language
is shorn
of the partisan load.
Read
it at the Akron Beacon Journal
|