Promoting the General Welfare
By Mike Stegall, Darke County Commissioner
I
read with interest Mr. Vic Bothast’s editorial (in the Daily
Advocate) on the federal government’s role in Healthcare.
He stated that the
government was to provide
health care to its citizens because of the “general welfare” clause in
the
Preamble to the Constitution. He
could
not be more wrong! The
“general welfare”
clause is mentioned twice in the Constitution, once in the preamble,
and once
in Article 1, Section 8. This
section of
the Constitution refers to the “general welfare” thus:
“The Congress shall have the power to
lay and
collect taxes, duties, imposts and excises, to pay the debts and
provide for
the common defense and general welfare of the United States…”
The
preamble clearly defines the two major functions of government:
(1) ensuring justice, personal freedom, and a free society where
individuals
are protected from domestic lawbreakers and criminals, and (2)
protecting
people of the United States from foreign aggressors.
When
the Founding Fathers said that “WE THE PEOPLE” established the
Constitution to “promote the general welfare”, they did not mean the
federal
government would have the power to aid education, build roads, and
subsidize
business. Likewise,
Article 1, Section
8, did not give Congress the right to use tax money for whatever social
and
economic programs Congress might think would be good for the “general
welfare”.
James
Madison stated that the “general welfare” clause was not
intended to give Congress an open hand “to exercise every power which
may be
alleged to be necessary for the common defense or general welfare.” If by the “general
welfare” the Founding
Fathers had meant any and all social, economic, or educational programs
Congress wanted to create, there would have been no reason to list
specific
powers of Congress such as establishing courts, and maintaining armed
forces. Those
powers would simply have been included
in one all-encompassing phrase, to promote the “general welfare.”
John
Quincy Adams observed:
“Our Constitution professedly rests upon
the good sense and attachment
of the people. This
basis, weak as it
may appear, has not yet been found to fail.”
Thomas
Jefferson wrote: “I consider the foundation of the
Constitution as laid on this ground: That ‘all powers not delegated to
the
United States, by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States,
are
reserved to the States or to the people.
To take a single step beyond the
boundaries thus specifically drawn
around the powers of Congress is to take possession of a boundless
field of
power, no longer susceptible of any definition.”
It
is NOT the government’s business (constitutionally) to “help”
individuals in financial difficulty. Once they undertake to provide
these kinds
of services, they must do so with limited resources, meaning that some
discriminating guidelines must be imposed. (so many who need that kind
of help -
so little resources to provide it).
The
Founding Fathers said in the preamble that one reason for
establishing the Constitution was to “promote the general welfare.” What they meant was that
the Constitution and
powers granted to the federal government were not to favor special
interest
groups or particular classes of people.
There were to be no privileged
individuals or groups in society.
Neither minorities nor the majority was
to be
favored. Rather,
the Constitution would
promote the “general welfare” by ensuring a free society where free,
self
responsible individuals - rich and poor, bankers and shopkeepers,
employers and
employees, farmers and others - would enjoy “life, liberty, and the
pursuit of
happiness,” rights expressed in the Declaration of Independence.
One
more item for all to ponder,
Thomas
Jefferson (the most brilliant of minds this country has ever
produced in my opinion) wrote in 1791 the danger of misinterpreting the
Constitution.
“The
danger in the hands of Senators and Congressmen is that of
instituting a Congress with power to do whatever would be for the good
of the
people of the United States; and, as they would be the sole judges of
the good
or evil, it would be also a power to do whatever evil they please.”
Unlike
public officials during Jefferson’s time, our modern day
legislators have a very loose interpretation of the Constitution. The result is that
government has mushroomed
into a monolithic bureaucracy, one that “WE THE PEOPLE” need to regain
control
of!
|